Mattress Toppers vs Mattress Protectors - What's the Difference?

Mattress Toppers vs Mattress Protectors - What's the Difference?

At Planet Linen we stock a huge range of Mattress protectors and mattress toppers by the biggest brands.

Many of our customers ask what is the difference? Well, while they may sound similar, they serve different purposes and offer unique benefits.

In this blog post, we'll explore the differences between these bedding essentials, outline their unique benefits, shed light on why investing in them is important, and offer a guide on selecting the ideal mattress topper or mattress protector according to your sleep preferences. Additionally, we'll briefly discuss related items such as pillow protectors. Lastly, we'll explore how mattress toppers can breathe new life into an aging mattress by restoring its support.

Understanding Mattress Toppers vs. Mattress Protectors:

    Mattress toppers and mattress protectors serve distinct yet equally significant functions in optimizing your sleep environment. While mattress toppers add an extra layer of comfort and support, mattress protectors act as a shield against spills, allergens, and wear and tear.

    Advantages of Mattress Toppers:

    Mattress toppers are designed to augment your existing mattress by offering additional cushioning and support. They come in various materials like memory foam, latex, or down alternatives, catering to diverse sleep preferences. Moreover, a mattress topper can breathe new life into an old mattress that has lost its firmness or support, providing a cost-effective solution to improve your sleep quality without replacing the entire mattress.

    Shop all MattressToppers

     Advantages of Mattress Protectors:

    On the other hand, mattress protectors act as a protective barrier, safeguarding your mattress from stains, spills, dust mites, and allergens. These covers not only prolong the lifespan of your mattress but also contribute to a healthier sleep environment, particularly for allergy sufferers.

    Shop all Mattress Protectors:

     Why Invest in Them:

    Investing in a quality mattress topper or protector is an investment in your comfort, health, and the longevity of your mattress. Both accessories offer distinct advantages that contribute to better sleep quality and protect your mattress from premature wear and tear.

    Choosing the Right One:

    Selecting the appropriate mattress topper or protector depends on factors such as your preferred sleep style, any specific health considerations, and the current condition of your mattress. 

    When selecting between mattress toppers and mattress protectors based on your sleep style, consider the following factors to ensure you make the most suitable choice:

    1. Sleep Position: Your preferred sleep position can influence your comfort needs. For instance, side sleepers might benefit from a mattress topper that offers ample cushioning and pressure relief, such as a memory foam or down alternative topper. Back or stomach sleepers might prefer a firmer topper or a mattress protector that maintains the mattress's support without significantly altering its feel.

    2. Temperature Regulation: If you tend to sleep hot, choosing a mattress topper or protector made from breathable materials like cotton or those with cooling gel-infused memory foam can help dissipate heat and promote a cooler sleep surface. Conversely, if you're often cold, opting for a thicker or insulating topper might provide extra warmth.

    3. Allergies or Sensitivities: If you have allergies or sensitivities, prioritizing a mattress protector designed to safeguard against allergens, dust mites, and other irritants could significantly improve your sleep quality. Look for protectors labeled as hypoallergenic and dust mite-resistant for added protection.

    4. Support Needs: Assess the current condition of your mattress. If it lacks support or has developed sagging areas, a mattress topper with additional firmness or support, such as a latex or high-density foam topper, might be beneficial. Alternatively, if your mattress is still supportive but requires protection, a mattress protector could be more suitable.

    5. Personal Comfort Preferences: Consider your personal preferences regarding mattress firmness, softness, and overall feel. A mattress topper can alter the feel of your mattress more noticeably than a protector, so choose one that aligns with your comfort preferences—whether you prefer a plush, medium, or firmer sleeping surface.

    6. Motion Isolation: For couples, if one partner frequently moves during sleep, a memory foam mattress topper can help reduce motion transfer, minimizing disturbances for the other person. However, if motion isolation isn't a concern, a mattress protector can still offer protection without altering the feel of the mattress significantly.             

    Pillow protectors serve as a valuable addition to your bedding, offering several advantages that contribute to a healthier and more comfortable sleep environment. Here are some key benefits of using pillow protectors:
    1. Allergen Protection: Pillow protectors act as a barrier against common allergens like dust mites, pollen, pet dander, and other irritants. They help reduce allergic reactions, making them particularly beneficial for allergy sufferers or those with asthma.

    2. Maintaining Cleanliness: These covers safeguard pillows from sweat, oils, drool, and stains, preventing these substances from penetrating into the pillow itself. This helps in maintaining the cleanliness and freshness of the pillow, making it easier to keep your bedding hygienic.

    3. Prolonging Pillow Lifespan: Pillow protectors provide an additional layer of defense against wear and tear. By protecting pillows from moisture and dirt, they help extend the life of your pillows, preserving their quality and durability over time.

    4. Hygienic and Easy to Clean: Pillow protectors are usually machine washable, making them easy to clean and maintain. Regularly washing pillow protectors helps ensure a cleaner sleep surface, contributing to better overall hygiene.

    5. Added Comfort and Versatility: Some pillow protectors are designed with soft and breathable materials that complement the feel of the pillow. They are available in various sizes and materials, catering to different preferences and pillow types, enhancing overall sleeping comfort.

    6. Preventing Bed Bugs: In addition to allergens, pillow protectors also act as a barrier against bed bugs, preventing them from infiltrating and nesting in your pillows.

    7. Preserving Warranty: Using pillow protectors often helps in preserving the warranty of your pillows, as they provide an additional layer of protection against damage, spills, or stains that might void the warranty otherwise.

    Shop all Pillow Protectors


    In this comprehensive guide, we hope we have assisted with the knowledge  to discern between mattress toppers and mattress protectors, understand their advantages, and make an informed decision when selecting the ideal one for your sleep sanctuary. Whether it's improving comfort, protecting your mattress, or revitalizing an old bed, these bedding accessories play a crucial role in optimizing your sleep experience.